Many appraise tales consisting of wit and mirth and compromise their time into digesting them. However, these so-called “fables” do not fail to disciple the listener in disrespect. Such is the tale of Chicibio and the Crane. And a summary of the tale lies in what follows.
Chicibio, they pompously declare, was the faithful servant to Mr. Currado, who was a nobleman, well renowned for his love of the hunt and feast. And it came to pass that the aristocrat’s falcon had caught a crane worthy of eating. Thus, the bird was handed to Chicibio, being told to ‘roast it to perfection’. And as it was nearly done, a beautiful peasant girl of Florence entered the kitchen and successfully persuaded the cook to grant her a leg. In due course, the platter (with of course, a missing leg) was carried to the nobleman’s table, which was punctually followed by a summoning of our main character, Chicibio. After Mr. Currado angrily interrogated the guilty servant, the latter retorted with his nose in the air, “Sire! I can prove that all cranes have one leg!” To this response, the nobleman exclaimed, “What? A crane with one leg? I have hunted birds far and wide and they all have two!” However, Chicibio still remained unmoved, and insisted that his point was correct. As Mr. Currado had no wish to argue in front of the guests, he coldly replied, “Fiat. Tomorrow, we shall see who is right, but woe betide you if you are proven wrong.” As the sun’s rays began to touch the trees of Florence, the aristocrat, in an even worse temper than the previous night, grimly rode off with the cook towards a river. Chicibio would have gladly fled in fear, but did not dare, as his courage failed him. When they arrived, the duo spotted a flock of cranes, fast asleep, one leg steadying each fowl. “Aha!” the servant cried, “I was correct!” “Indeed!” snorted Mr. Currado. He swiftly clapped his hands and shouted. At the sudden sound, the cranes shot up into the air like rockets. “But, Sire, if you had clapped and shouted at the feast, then the crane would have uncurled its other leg!” Such was the swiftness of the answer which Chicibio uttered, that it still flabbergasted the nobleman in his later years. Thus, due to the servant’s wit, the nobleman and Chicibio parted as friends. Behold, the story of Chicibio and the Crane, and to withdraw a knife from butter is equivalent to testing it.
What is the probability of a peasant entering a rich man’s kitchen? And perchance she did arrive, would an aristocrat’s cook risk his position for the satisfaction of one lesser in rank than he is? Beauty is more persuasive than one’s own duty. Would one forfeit his livelihood for the sake of vanity? In addition, would one currently preoccupied with important matters notice another’s presence? In regards to these factors, I provide two choices: that Chicibio was not as trustworthy as the story proclaims, or he had attempted to sabotage on the nobleman’s feast.
Let us fancy that the cook indeed managed to procure a leg of meat. Why then would Chichibio lie to his master, twice jeopardizing his livelihood? Had he fabricated the tale, why present it before Currado’s guests? Human instinct compels us to flee from uncomfortable situations. Yet he did not retreat from the hall; instead, he chose to double down on his deceit. One must conclude that Chichibio either jested with intent or harbored a self-destructive desire to forfeit his position. Yet, the cook’s true aim was merely to entertain the company. Would a servant so boldly mock his master? In surrendering the crane’s leg to the peasant woman, “the witty cook” would have made a remarkably foolish bargain.
Even if we grant the tale this premise, another question arises: why did Mr. Currado refrain from rebuking Chichibio? A nobleman does not acquire his status through foolishness, but through discernment. If insolence goes unpunished, what is to stop a servant from repeating the offense? No one possessing true wisdom would tolerate dishonesty under their own roof. Indeed, how can a man rightfully call himself master if he cannot command discipline within his own house? Masters command servants; do servants then, in return, command their masters?
And we reach another objection. It is said that as Chicibio and his master were approaching a river, the former spied a flock supporting his argument. Would a trustworthy servant stop on the first sedge he sees supporting his own cause? Additionally, how could one, forming an excuse in front of guests, be afraid of flight in private? Knowing this, one can assume two positions; either Chicibio was determined to mock his master, or he was no more than a liar.
Moreover, why did Chicibio suggest an improper action to his master in a banquet? If it is a servant’s duty to aid his master, (which is undoubtedly true) then foolish advice would be contrary to the cook’s position. In doing so, he attempts, whether intentional or not, to harm his master. Is it proper for a majordomo to assail a nobleman with impudence and unwise words? If Mr. Currado had indeed followed Chicibio’s instruction, would not both be out of place? Then Chicibio must have not desired a profession under the nobleman’s house, for all his doings potentially expel him from his position.
Furthermore, would one angry so easily pardon a subject? For those in wrath do not heed calm words, but contrastingly leap up at the smallest spark. How then would Mr. Currado be amused at Chicibio’s remarks? Indeed, a witty remark does not turn away anger, but more likely would kindle it. However, if it is true that the aristocrat and the servant parted as friends, then the nobleman could not have been truly angry at his cook.
Let calamity fall upon such tales as this, lest I appear to condemn all things.